I’ve realised recently that there are actually quite a number of things I’ve been meaning to write about for a while, so now that I have this blog I’m going to put them all here, in no particular order. Today I am going to write about Jerusalem.
I’m not sure what I can say about Jerusalem that hasn’t already been said by somebody at some point in its long history, but I’ll have a go anyway. Because I didn’t grow up in a Jewish environment, I suppose I never really thought about Jerusalem as a place that people actually went to. It was more the place people talked about in my historical novels, where Crusades and pilgrimages happened and where there probably were not any dark satanic mills. And then I met my husband and made some Jewish friends and heard them talk about the Israel tour they had all been on as teenagers, and all their experiences in Jerusalem, and began to think of it as a real city rather than a place in a story. And then I started my conversion and began to think of it in all sorts of other ways as well. And then when I finally stepped in through Jaffa Gate and saw all the monks and priests and shopkeepers and tourists and Haredim and hawkers and people just going about their daily lives in the city, all of those disparate images of Jerusalem suddenly came together and it felt…enormous. Significant. Overwhelming. I don’t know. We spent days just walking around the Old City, and up on the ramparts looking down on it (that’s where I took the photo at the top of this blog page. Sorry it’s a bit blurry).
I went to the Western Wall twice. The first time I just went to see it – I brought my little red siddur and prayed Mincha quietly to myself, and then I sat down and watched for a while. There weren’t very many people there: the women’s side was crowded, but there was plenty of space on the men’s side. The second time, it was the morning of Rosh Chodesh Elul, and I was going to pray with the Women of the Wall.
I got there early – it must have been about 6:30, and the plaza was beautiful in the early morning light (I love that quality of light you get in very hot countries before the day has started to warm up, when everything looks so clear and bright and fresh, and the shadows are so sharp and the breeze smells good). This time the men’s side was more crowded – groups of men swayed and sang and chanted together, some of them dancing, some blowing shofarot for the first day of Elul. I sat and listened for a while – I’m not used to the Orthodox style of prayer (where you basically just pray away at your own pace and everybody starts and finishes at different points), and I was surprised at how beautiful it sounded. Their voices were like waves, rushing in and out and occasionally coming together in a great swell of feeling when they all reached the same bit of text at once, and the wail of the shofar over it all. Our side was silent, of course, though there were many women standing or sitting near the wall, whispering tearfully into their siddurim, or pressed up against the Wall, appearing overcome with emotion. It’s actually only just occurred to me that none of them appeared happy in any way – they were all either on the verge of tears, or solemn and devout-looking. Perhaps it’s hard to express joy silently (though that can’t be the whole story – I know I’ve expressed silent joy before). The silence felt thick and liquid, like oil, and I couldn’t quite believe that in a few minutes a group of women was going to arrive to break it. It seemed like such a brave and impossible thing to do.
They turned up with their assigned policeman (who nodded at us in amused tolerance, like a sympathetic policeman of the 1900s keeping an eye on suffragettes: ‘all right, ladies? How are we all this morning?’), and six soldiers stationed themselves discreetly on the men’s side of the mechitzah to prevent any trouble. The silence on our side of the mechitzah shattered as the service began, and their voices climbed high as they sang the Hallel psalms. It was beautiful. I was moved. The men turned up the volume on their side to drown us out, and a few women came to shout at us, tell us how we were disturbing others’ prayer and we should be ashamed of ourselves and all the rest of it, but nobody threw anything at us, and the anger couldn’t spoil the simple, amazing experience of standing there in joyful prayer in the place where Jews prayed two thousand years ago, in a different world, before a long exile. I didn’t actually intend to attach such significance to the Wall – it’s just a wall, right? The Jews who built it would barely recognise us as Jews, anyway – but I found that the significance attached itself anyway, and I could do nothing to stop it. I lost myself in singing the words עָזִּי וְזִמְרָת יָהּ וַיְהִי לִי לִישׁוּעָה, ozi v’zimrat Yah, vay’hi li lishuah, ‘God is my strength and song, and will be my salvation’ and joy welled over in me.
Women are still not allowed to read from the Torah at the Wall, or to blow the shofar, so halfway through the service we headed away from the plaza to Robinson’s Arch, an archaeological site a little way away. We sang as we walked, and as we passed, Charedi men closed their eyes and stuck their fingers in their ears so they wouldn’t hear our voices. I am genuinely saddened that our form of prayer disrupts the prayer of others (though if those others recognised women as actual people with equal rights to men we wouldn’t have this problem in the first place), but…they presumably come to pray at the Kotel regularly? Surely they know the Women of the Wall meet every Rosh Chodesh at 7am – if they can’t bear to hear the voices of women is it really that much trouble to stay away for one hour a month? So I have to admit I felt a certain sense of power watching them turn away from us.
We finished our service at Robinson’s Arch. There was a Bat Mitzvah. A woman leyned beautifully, and another blew the shofar for us, and then we dispersed. I headed back to my hostel to meet my husband for breakfast and tell him all about my experience. It’s easy to feel angry about the Charedi monopolisation of the Wall, about the many limitations placed on the people who go to pray there and especially about the silencing of women. I get angry about it often (even though it’s only a wall and I don’t believe in fetishising masonry, etc etc). But when I think of my experience at Rosh Chodesh, my memory is all joy – the proud voices breaking the silence together, the morning light, the birds wheeling overhead, the sound of the shofar. God is my strength and song, and will be my salvation.